MORTGAGE GRADER, INC. v. FIRST CHOICE LOAN SERVICES (Fed. Cir. 2016) (P) – Operations that can be performed by humans without a computer are generally directed to an abstract idea

Operations that can be performed by humans without a computer are generally directed to an abstract idea despite any further recitation of computer hardware. Here, for example, a method of anonymously evaluating a potential borrower for a loan using a third-party...

ETHICON ENDO-SURGERY, INC. v. COVIDIEN LP (Fed. Cir. 2016) (P) – The same Board panel can make the decision to institute inter partes review and the final determination

Neither the AIA statute nor the Constitution precludes the same panel of the Board that made the decision to institute inter partes review from making the final determination. Background / Facts: The patent on appeal here from inter partes review proceedings at the...

WI-LAN, INC. v. APPLE INC. (Fed. Cir. 2016) (P) – Even small differences can be sufficient to defeat infringement under the doctrine of equivalents

Even small differences in operation or design can be sufficient to defeat infringement under the doctrine of equivalents. Here, for example, a parallel architecture that inverted the order of operations for data encoding as compared to the claimed invention, and...

**YEAR IN REVIEW 2015**

As 2015 officially comes to a close, we are pleased to present our annual comprehensive guide to all the happenings in patent prosecution case law over the last year. We hope that you will find it useful as a handy reference in your practice. Digital download: Year in...